Broadbent v Medical Board of Queensland
[2010] QCA 311
To print this judgment please return to the case and click on the PDF icon
next to the
case name. For court use, a full PDF copy is required or preferred.
CITATION: | Broadbent v Medical Board of Queensland [2010] QCA 311 |
JUDGE(S): | Fraser JA |
DELIVERED ON: | 09 November 2010 |
Broadbent v Medical Board of Queensland
Broadbent v Medical Board of Queensland
[2010] QCA 311
QCA
Fraser JA
09 Nov 2010
Event | Citation or File | Date | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Primary Judgment | SC No 8399 of 2008 (no citation) | 05 Sep 2008 | Dr Broadbent applied for judicial review of Medical Board's pending decision to suspend him from practice as a medical practitioner; where no decision had been made; application dismissed: Philippides J |
Primary Judgment | [2009] QHPT 13 | 07 Sep 2009 | Dr Broadbent applied for permanent stay or dismissal of thirteen referral notices upon the giving of an undertaking not to practice medicine in Australia; application dismissed: Wall QC DCJ |
Primary Judgment | [2010] QCAT 280 | 10 Jun 2010 | Hearing of two amended referral notices; finding of two instances of unsatisfactory professional conduct against Dr Broadbent: Wall QC DCJ assisted by Dr P Richardson, Dr G Powell and Ms G Bolland |
Primary Judgment | [2010] QCAT 488 | 02 Sep 2010 | Penalty hearing regarding unsatisfactory professional conduct found in [2010] QCAT 280; undertaking given by Dr Broadbent to retire permanently from medical practice and not to reapply within Australia: Wall QC DCJ assisted by Dr P Richardson, Dr G Powell and Ms G Bolland |
Primary Judgment | [2010] QCAT 507 | 22 Oct 2010 | Medical Board applied its costs of the proceeding; Dr Broadbent ordered to pay 70% of the costs of the hearing: Wall QC DCJ assisted by Dr P Richardson, Dr G Powell and Ms G Bolland |
Primary Judgment | [2011] FCA 980 195 FCR 438; 282 ALR 96; 123 ALD 280 | 25 Aug 2011 | Dr Broadbent applied for judicial review of [2010] QCAT 280; where no ground of jurisdiction identified; application dismissed with indemnity costs: Greenwood J |
Primary Judgment | [2012] QCAT 120 | 22 Mar 2012 | Following appeal process of [2010] QCAT 280, QCAT gave leave to Medical Board to withdraw remaining 11 referral notices; Dr Broadbent applied for costs of those referrals; parties to bear their own costs: Kingham DCJ Deputy President |
Primary Judgment | [2014] FCCA 1406 | 29 May 2014 | Dr Broadbent applied to set aside Bankruptcy Notice founded on costs order in [2010] QCAT 507, contending that Medical Board of Australia was not the proper creditor because it did not exist at that time; application dismissed: Burnett J |
Primary Judgment | Medical Board of Australia (no citation or file number) | 10 Jun 2014 | Dr Broadbent applied to Medical Board for general registration as a medical practitioner; application refused as contrary to orders made in [2010] QCAT 488 |
Primary Judgment | [2014] QCATA 329 | 25 Nov 2014 | Dr Broadbent applied to "strike out" the directions of 24 October 2014 permitting the Medical Board to be legally represented; application dismissed: Horneman-Wren SC DCJ |
Primary Judgment | [2015] FCA 717 214 FCR 419 | 15 Jul 2015 | Dr Broadbent appealed against [2014] FCCA 1406; where new grounds of appeal raised at hearing; leave granted to rely on new grounds, appeal allowed and bankruptcy orders set aside: Rangiah J |
Primary Judgment | [2018] QCAT 25 | 16 Feb 2018 | Medical Board applied to strike out Dr Broadbent's appeal against its decision of 10 June 2014 refusing his registration; appeal found to be vexatious and an abuse of process and struck out: Horneman-Wren SC DCJ assisted by Dr M Humphrey, Dr D Evans and Mr K Dahl |
Primary Judgment | [2018] QCAT 408 | 14 Dec 2018 | Medical Board applied for its costs of [2018] QCAT 25; costs ordered against Dr Broadbent on an indemnity basis: Horneman-Wren SC DCJ |
QCA Interlocutory Judgment | [2010] QCA 311 | 09 Nov 2010 | Dr Broadbent applied for leave to appeal against [2010] QCAT 280; Medical Board of Queensland cross-applied for declarations that appeal had been compromised and sought disclosure of documents from Dr Broadbent; disclosure ordered: Fraser JA |
Appeal Determined (QCA) | [2010] QCA 352 | 10 Dec 2010 | Hearing of Dr Broadbent's application for leave to appeal and Medical Board's application for declarations; Medical Board's application refused and application for leave to appeal dismissed with costs: Fraser and Chesterman JJA and PD McMurdo J |
Appeal Determined (QCA) | [2019] QCA 139 | 16 Jul 2019 | Dr Broadbent applied for leave to appeal from [2018] QCAT 25 and to adduce further evidence on appeal; applications refused: Fraser and Philippides JJA and Bond J |
Special Leave Refused (HCA) | [2016] HCASL 22 | 05 Apr 2016 | Medial Board applied for special leave to appeal against [2015] FCA 717; application dismissed with costs: Bell and Gageler JJ |
Special Leave Refused (HCA) | [2019] HCASL 308 | 10 Oct 2019 | Dr Broadbent applied for an extension of time in which to seek special leave to appeal against [2019] QCA 139; application dismissed: Nettle and Gordon JJ |