Hannover International Ltd v C W Robson
[2012] QSC 47
To print this judgment please return to the case and click on the PDF icon
next to the
case name. For court use, a full PDF copy is required or preferred.
Hannover International Ltd v C W Robson; Mine & Quarry Equipment International v C W Robson; G F Robson v C W Robson & Anor
Hannover International Ltd v C W Robson
[2012] QSC 47
QSC
A Lyons J
08 Mar 2012
Event | Citation or File | Date | Notes |
---|---|---|---|
Primary Judgment | [2003] QSC 176 | 02 Jun 2003 | Strike out application in proceeding 8937/00; unpersuaded that any part of the defence and counterclaim of CWR ought be struck out on the basis that it discloses no reasonable cause of action or amounts to an abuse of the process of the court: Ambrose J. |
Primary Judgment | [2007] QSC 217 | 17 Aug 2007 | Strike out application by plaintiff against third further amended defence; tax fraud case ought to be struck out because it is so devoid of particularity that it would prejudice a fair trial of the action; other fraud case should be struck out because it discloses no reasonable defence: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | SC10177/04 (No Citation) | 25 Sep 2007 | Application for security for costs; application dismissed. |
Primary Judgment | [2008] QSC 238 | 03 Oct 2008 | Application to strike out paragraphs of defence; allegation that the 1995 declarations were shams, is embarrassing and should be struck out, at least because it is unsupported by the stated basis of “the premises”: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | [2009] QSC 62 | 26 Mar 2009 | Application to strike out paragraphs of defence; allege that part of this money found its way to Yalgold, and that the plaintiff should be refused equitable relief because he is effectively seeking to recover the fruits of his fraud; in essence the same case the subject of pleadings stuck out in August 2007 and again in October 2008: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | [2009] QSC 325 | 08 Oct 2009 | Application to strike out parts of defences in three related proceedings (10177/04, 7342/00, 8937/00); duplicate of plea previously struck out in 10177/04; pleas in other proceedings remain: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | [2010] QSC 378 | 07 Oct 2010 | Application to stay 10177/04 dismissed and application for security for costs in each proceeding dismissed; defendants ultimately complain that they cannot be given a fair trial because of alleged deficiencies in the supplementary disclosure made to them no less than five months prior to this application being heard: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | [2011] QSC 234 | 12 Aug 2011 | Judgment on trial of three related proceedings arising from brothers falling out in business; allegation that shares in entity owner of real property are held on trust, based on declarations of trust; declaration made that the defendants hold half of their shares in the company on trust for the plaintiff (10177/04) and proceedings 7342 and 8937 of 2000 ordered in favour of defendant: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | [2011] QSC 301 | 05 Oct 2011 | Costs judgment following trial judgment in [2011] QSC 234; plaintiff pay costs of proceeding on dismissed claims: McMurdo J. |
Primary Judgment | [2012] QSC 47 | 08 Mar 2012 | Application to review cost assessment on orders made on 1 Match 2010 that the plaintiffs pay the defendants‟ „costs as a result of the adjournment of the trial‟ on an indemnity basis after the trial was adjourned after five days of hearing due to the plaintiff‟s late disclosure; application dismissed: A Lyons J. |
Appeal Determined (QCA) | [2008] QCA 36 | 29 Feb 2008 | Appeal dismissed with costs; appeal against refusal of application for security for costs; nothing in the justice of the case that required the making of the order: Keane and Muir JJA and McMeekin J. |
Appeal Determined (QCA) | [2010] QCA 330 | 26 Nov 2010 | Appeal against dismissal of applications in [2010] QSC 378 dismissed with costs; no strong reasons demonstrated to warrant intervention: Muir and Chesterman JJA and Philippides J. |
Appeal Determined (QCA) | [2012] QCA 119 | 04 May 2012 | Appeal against trial judgment [2011] QSC 234 dismissed with costs; alleged errors in findings of trial judge not made out: Muir, Fraser and White JJA. |
Special Leave Refused (HCA) | [2012] HCASL 175 | 05 Dec 2012 | Application for special leave to appeal [2012] QCA 119 dismissed with costs: Hayne and Crennan JJ. |